I’ll show you my Flock if you show me yours

Leave a comment

It appears that the Tulare County Sheriff’s Office has given it’s JAG grant money to Visalia Police Department, to use towards the city’s Flock ALPR system, and gains access to the Flock network.

At the moment, the Tulare County Sheriff’s Office has not installed any Flock Automated License Plate Reader cameras itself. If does not have a paid subscription (as far as I can determine) to Flock services. It *CAN*, however, access the Flock network. Although TCSO has a seperate MOU with Flock, it’s unclear if they have their own log-in access, or if they operate as an authorized user of Visalia’s contract.

TCSO has a similar policy regarding ALPR systems to VPD’s. In fact, it’s the almost exactly the same, even down to the section numbers. Clearly both departments are not re-inventing the wheel, as they appear to have taken a document from some other police agency and adapted it to their own needs. Here’s the Sheriff’s Office policy:

Here’s VPD’s policy:

I’ve now filed California Public Records Act requests with both agencies for the training materials used to become authorized to access Flock data.

This is essentially the same thing I requested of VPD:

I sent the request to TCSO on 11/19/2026, and the request to VPD on 11/8/2026.

Dribs and drabs.

My previous posts about Flock:

Needles in the Flock Haystack

Leave a comment

Image generated by Gemini AI

On September 10, 2026, I filed a California Public Records Act request of the City of Visalia, and the Visalia Police Department. On October 5, I got my response.

A lot to digest there, but let’s start with “5. The Department’s case/incident number is withheld.” A lot of verbiage to deny giving me the case numbers associated with each incident that was allegedly solved with the use of the Flock ALPR system.

They’re also saying they don’t have to release “arrest and incident information” that is more than a year old, and that “much” of my requested information predates that by “many months”, but they are giving it to me (minus what they decided to withhold) “in the interest of transparency”.

They tell me how generous they were being by including information that was more than a year old, citing a court case that they claim means they didn’t have to.

Visalia, I hate to say it, but “transparency” went out the window a long time ago. (Encrypting police radio transmissions and removing a data field on the Flock transparency page was just the beginning.)

Other information gleaned from the “response” –

From January 1, 2025 through May 29, 2026, there were 123 incidents solved which were attributed to Flock ALPR use by the Visalia Police Department.

To justify mass surveillance, proponents of ALPR systems often talk about two types of incidents: missing persons, and stolen cars. In Visalia’s record, there are no cases of missing persons found using the Flock system. Out of 123 incidents that were attributed to the Flock system, only 45 are stolen vehicles.

Six were violent crimes – assault with a deadly weapon, armed robbery, and a home invasion.

The rest of the cases “solved” by Flock ALPR data are not classified as violent crimes.

I had asked for location information, as well. Either addresses of incidents, or the hundred block and street name. They refused to provide that, stating the “existing” data only listed VPD “area” zones, and they didn’t have to provide the address or location information more detailed than that.

In the time period covered by the data released, Flock ALPR cameras took more than 5,950,000 images of license plates. Perhaps many more. The “transparency” page lists an average monthly “unique plate reads” of more than 300,000 every 30 days. Multiply that by the 17 months of data released, and the total number surveillance images is staggering.

And, at $3,000 a year per camera, expensive. (The cameras are not bought by and owned by Visalia. They are a subscription. The cameras and related equipment remain the property of Flock.)

Tell Me About This Particular Flock Camera

Leave a comment

On August 26, 2016, I filed a California Public Records Act request with the City of Visalia regarding this particular Flock camera. It’s located on Demaree Street, just south of Goshen Avenue, in Visalia. When I noticed it one day driving by, I had questions.

There are all kinds of requirements for things close to city streets, especially for those items in the public right-of-way. I decided to check to see if those requirements had been met for this installation. I wrote a very involved public records request about it, and got my reply today.

The response was underwhelming.

Either most of my request was ignored, or the City let this thing be put up with almost no oversight, and in violation of it’s own documents regarding the installation.

Here’s the complete response to my request. I’ll add the entire request at the end of this blog, as it’s quite extensive.

More

Something I heard on the radio today

Leave a comment

Shaaron Claridge

I was listening to Visalia PD on the radio earlier today, when one of the dispatchers gave a return to an officer in the field, and it struck me as almost eerie.  She sounded very much like the dispatcher heard on the Adam-12 television series!

The interesting thing about the “voice actress” who voiced “Adam-12, Adam-12, see the woman…” and my favorite, “Adam-12, a 211 just occurred, Adam-12, handle code 3!” is she was a REAL police dispatcher, with the Van Nuys division of the Los Angeles Police Department!  She worked part time as a voice actor, and did the dispatch for several police shows through the years.  Can you imagine the double takes people would do, if they listened to early police scanners, or happened to be standing next to a LAPD police car, and heard that voice come across the speakers?  “Hey!  That’s the lady from Adam-12!”  Her husband was a motorcycle officer with LAPD, too.

I look at her dispatch console, a desk, really, and think…  wow!  How things have changed!

My work station