To “bury the lede” means to start a story, article, or conversation with secondary details while hiding or delaying the most important and newsworthy fact. City of Visalia, I’m looking at you.

On November 6, 2023, this item appeared on the Visalia City Council’s consent agenda. Rather innocuous looking, isn’t it? This is where the public trail begins in Visalia’s Flock saga. You’ll notice this item does not mention Flock, or ALPR (automated license plate reader) details. It just looks like the police department is getting money from a grant for something, and entering into some kind of agreement with the Sheriff’s Office. All nice and neat and dull. If you’re at a City Council meeting, and you’ve picked up the printed agenda to peruse, that’s all you see.

If you have access to the internet, though, you might find this:

The first mention of ALPR is at the bottom of the first page of this document. Later, is this statement: “Visalia Police Chief, Jason Salazar, reached out to Sheriff Mike Boudreaux at the Tulare County Sheriff’s Office and agreed to the joint purchase program.“

There is no “joint purchase program”, as there is no purchase. The City is buying nothing. It will be a subscription to a service. The City of Visalia will own exactly no equipment. No poles. No solar panels. No cameras. It doesn’t even control the equipment eventually installed, so it’s not even a rental or lease of something tangible. Everything remains the property of, and under the control of, Flock Safety. It gets even “better”, though. There’s a twist at the end of this blog that I just discovered. It’s not good.

The item was not pulled from the consent calendar for separate consideration, which means there was no discussion about the proposal. The entire consent calendar was passed 5-0.

The next time we see a public mention of the Flock subscription is October 21, 2024, in another consent calendar item.

And the actual complete agenda packet item:

This is the first time the consent calendar listing mentions Flock ALPR in the initial notice, and it is not buried in the agenda packet information. The item was not pulled, and the entire consent calendar was passed 5-0.

Now we jump to January 21, 2025. You’ll notice that again there is no mention of the Flock ALPR subscription, just text about accepting and appropriating the funds from a grant.

Like the previous agenda packet, you have to get to the bottom of the first page to see that this is the ALPR Flock system. It is interesting that under “Prior Council Action”, they list “None” in two prior agenda packets. I’m going to assume that was just a ‘copy and paste’ error that slipped through. This item was also not pulled, and the consent calendar was passed 3-0, with council members Nelsen and Wynn absent.

Now we jump to September 21, 2026 for the next council action. More grant funding to be accepted and appropriated for the Flock ALPR camera subscription (about $3,000 per year per camera).

And the agenda packet with the relevant(?) information.

Again with the “Prior Council Action: None”. I don’t think that word (none) means what they think it means.

This is the meeting where the Visalia Police Department gives a public presentation during the regular session, regular items section. Police Chief Jason Salazar said “…given the questions and concerns either from members of the public or that we’ve seen on social media, we elected to bring this as a regular item…” (I think I may be responsible for some of that). He also said, “As council was [is] aware, typically grant approvals come to the council on the consent calendar…”, which explains the “official” reason prior requests were on the consent calendar.

Here’s their presentation:

Here’s the YouTube video of that presentation:

So that’s where we sit with Flock, as far as the City of Visalia, and the Visalia Police Department is concerned. They love them their Flock cameras. They credit the solving of two homicides, and a reduction of stolen vehicle reports (but one wonders how they can attribute a reduction in the STOLEN numbers to Flock, when almost nobody knew the cameras were present), but no missing persons recovered (at least in the time period of January 1, 2025 to May 29, 2026, which is the information I received in a California Public Records Act request). A missing elderly person is often one of the incident types ALPR supporters cite as a reason to have these cameras up in a city.

Oh, and that ‘twist’ I mentioned at the beginning?

I’ve said, on more than one occasion, that I’m not against the idea of license plate readers in general. I am worried about this system not being under the control of the police department. The servers that hold millions of the images collected, and hundreds of thousands maintained for the 30-day retention periods, are not in Visalia. Up until very recently, I thought they were in a Flock server farm somewhere, accessible by anyone Flock would let in. And being hooked to the Internet means they are susceptible to hacking, regardless of what Flock claims as “never being hacked”.

It turns out they are not.

Flock contracts with Amazon, and uses it’s AWS GovCloud (US) to store it’s billions of images and data files.

I wonder how many of those “Data Centers” in the news recently are, or will be, dedicated to the ever-increasing storage and computing requirements of these surveillance networks popping up across the country? Flock requires users to allow them to use the data (anonymized) to train their AI. That’s scary just in itself.

I suppose I prefer the GovCloud system over Flock hosting it’s own servers, but it’s not really comforting to me. It adds another layer of vulnerability to unauthorized access to the data. With the way Flock loves to be very precise in it’s wording, I suppose their claim that “Flock has never been hacked” could be technically correct. Almost any hack would be at Amazon. (I wonder if Amazon is the root cause of “system bugs” and “feature reactivations” Flock blamed for unauthorized nationwide access to California data, in violation of SB 34, in February and March of 2024, and a 9-week window in late 2024?)

While there is an upswing in public sentiment across the country against Flock and other ALPR systems, Visalians have been mostly quiet about them. There has been almost no public comment in City Council meetings, and little other visible social media posts speaking out against them. If 24/7/365 monitoring of their travel by the government doesn’t bother them, there will be no political pressure on the council to end the subscription, and call for the removal of the cameras.

We’ll see what happens next. I’m not hopeful at this point.

My previous blogs about Flock Safety Automated License Plate Readers: