Space. The Final Frontier.
First it was Star Trek. Now it’s Star Wars. I don’t like where this is going.
You know who I’m talking about, right? J.J. Abrams? The wunderkind of movies these days? In my little world, he’s trashed the Enterprise, and now he’s killed Han Solo. Is nothing sacred?
OK, I suppose *he* didn’t kill Han. The story is Harrison Ford wanted the character to die back in the carbonite block, but was talked out of it (read $$$). But still. Bad Robot.
First, the Enterprise. I really like the bridge of the new version starship. Especially the ’embedded-in-the-window’ viewscreen. That was a cool idea. The engine room, and whatever those huge tank things were, is just… not. Unless the Enterprise is really a TARDIS, there’s just no way all that inside fits the outside. Huge gaping spaces for our heros to dangle from is just nuts. That thing-a-ma-jig that Kirk kicks back into alignment? Bad scripting there, plain and simple. Really poor starship design. The same engineers that came up with the viewscreen-window couldn’t come up with a better doo-dad for Kirk to fix at the last second? Really? And those lens flares. Really annoying. Bad Robot.
I just saw Star Wars – The Force Awakens. Not much force awakening going on there. A lot of spaceship-blowing-up and what-not, but the force is not strong in this one. More vast spaces to dangle the hero from, but mostly a re-hash. We’ve pretty much seen this movie, before we’ve even seen it. Bad Robot.
Nit-picking. Did nobody do an after-action assessment when they lost the Death Star? Nobody noticed the glaring design flaw in the super-weapon? They basically built the same thing again, only bigger? And using a star as a power source? In such a way that you suck up the star itself to power the weapon? Seems like a lot of money and resources to put into a weapon with a limited shelf-life! The Dark Side seems to have a rather large blind spot. Probably as big as the ego of the latest evil leader. Bad Empire/First Order.
And haven’t we already seen this plot device? The weapon is charging/coming into range! We have only minutes before the rebel base is zapped! Everyone’s about to die! But wait! Our heroes blow up the Death Star/Star Killer in the nick of time, saving everyone! I suppose if he’s going to re-hash old Star Trek movies, J.J. doesn’t worry about doing it in Star Wars, too. Bad Robot.
I wonder if Mark Hamill is going to be able to pull off his own Obi-Wan in the next movie? Can we believe Luke going full-Yoda on us? Time will tell. JJ Abrams won’t be directing it, so maybe we’ll get something more George Lucas-like. But it’s Disney, now, so maybe not. Especially after George’s crack about them.
This movie didn’t seem to really advance the story much. I suppose it’s more a hat-tip to the previous films, and to set up the two to follow. Seems a bit weak to be a top-grossing movie, but it does show the desire of the public to revisit this galaxy. Disney and company seem determined to give them what they want. The merchandising for this episode has just been insane. Even a YouTube light saber gizmo on the control thingy? Really? Bad Robot.
The 3D version was pretty neat. I enjoyed it, and most of the time didn’t realize I was watching a 3D movie. When you don’t notice the effect, they’re doing it right. Good Robot.
I went to the last showing on a Sunday night, and had the auditorium to myself. Just me and the movie. That’s both cool, and a little creepy at the same time. Watching the opening crawl and then the closing credits in 3D was strangely mesmerizing.
Overall, I’d give it 4 out of 5 stars. Excellent effects, especially in 3D, likable new characters, and the possibility of decent follow-on stories. Dinged for re-hashed story and plot, no clear emotional buildup on Ben’s part to Han’s death (Ben did not seem conflicted, nor did the murder seem like his climax to completing his journey to the Dark Side), and it’s poor use of R2-D2 and C3PO.
JimmieJoe 
This new guy really is a Bad Robot
January 18, 2016
Jim Reeves commentary, fiction, geek, Personal bb8, jj abrams, star trek, Star Wars, tardis, the force awakens, USS Enterprise Leave a comment
Space. The Final Frontier.
First it was Star Trek. Now it’s Star Wars. I don’t like where this is going.
You know who I’m talking about, right? J.J. Abrams? The wunderkind of movies these days? In my little world, he’s trashed the Enterprise, and now he’s killed Han Solo. Is nothing sacred?
OK, I suppose *he* didn’t kill Han. The story is Harrison Ford wanted the character to die back in the carbonite block, but was talked out of it (read $$$). But still. Bad Robot.
First, the Enterprise. I really like the bridge of the new version starship. Especially the ’embedded-in-the-window’ viewscreen. That was a cool idea. The engine room, and whatever those huge tank things were, is just… not. Unless the Enterprise is really a TARDIS, there’s just no way all that inside fits the outside. Huge gaping spaces for our heros to dangle from is just nuts. That thing-a-ma-jig that Kirk kicks back into alignment? Bad scripting there, plain and simple. Really poor starship design. The same engineers that came up with the viewscreen-window couldn’t come up with a better doo-dad for Kirk to fix at the last second? Really? And those lens flares. Really annoying. Bad Robot.
I just saw Star Wars – The Force Awakens. Not much force awakening going on there. A lot of spaceship-blowing-up and what-not, but the force is not strong in this one. More vast spaces to dangle the hero from, but mostly a re-hash. We’ve pretty much seen this movie, before we’ve even seen it. Bad Robot.
Nit-picking. Did nobody do an after-action assessment when they lost the Death Star? Nobody noticed the glaring design flaw in the super-weapon? They basically built the same thing again, only bigger? And using a star as a power source? In such a way that you suck up the star itself to power the weapon? Seems like a lot of money and resources to put into a weapon with a limited shelf-life! The Dark Side seems to have a rather large blind spot. Probably as big as the ego of the latest evil leader. Bad Empire/First Order.
And haven’t we already seen this plot device? The weapon is charging/coming into range! We have only minutes before the rebel base is zapped! Everyone’s about to die! But wait! Our heroes blow up the Death Star/Star Killer in the nick of time, saving everyone! I suppose if he’s going to re-hash old Star Trek movies, J.J. doesn’t worry about doing it in Star Wars, too. Bad Robot.
I wonder if Mark Hamill is going to be able to pull off his own Obi-Wan in the next movie? Can we believe Luke going full-Yoda on us? Time will tell. JJ Abrams won’t be directing it, so maybe we’ll get something more George Lucas-like. But it’s Disney, now, so maybe not. Especially after George’s crack about them.
This movie didn’t seem to really advance the story much. I suppose it’s more a hat-tip to the previous films, and to set up the two to follow. Seems a bit weak to be a top-grossing movie, but it does show the desire of the public to revisit this galaxy. Disney and company seem determined to give them what they want. The merchandising for this episode has just been insane. Even a YouTube light saber gizmo on the control thingy? Really? Bad Robot.
The 3D version was pretty neat. I enjoyed it, and most of the time didn’t realize I was watching a 3D movie. When you don’t notice the effect, they’re doing it right. Good Robot.
I went to the last showing on a Sunday night, and had the auditorium to myself. Just me and the movie. That’s both cool, and a little creepy at the same time. Watching the opening crawl and then the closing credits in 3D was strangely mesmerizing.
Overall, I’d give it 4 out of 5 stars. Excellent effects, especially in 3D, likable new characters, and the possibility of decent follow-on stories. Dinged for re-hashed story and plot, no clear emotional buildup on Ben’s part to Han’s death (Ben did not seem conflicted, nor did the murder seem like his climax to completing his journey to the Dark Side), and it’s poor use of R2-D2 and C3PO.
Share this: