
At the October 21, 2024 City Council meeting, Consent Agenda item #6, file #24-0415, was approved with no separate discussion. That item was to enter into an agreement with Flock Safety out of Atlanta, Georgia, for their Automated License Plate Reader subscription service. Visalia Police Department wanted to install 22 cameras around the city, and have access to 18 other cameras operated by other organizations, for a total of 40 installations.
The issue here? The agenda packet does not reflect the reality of what the City Council was being asked to approve.
The information provided to the City Council says, “The Visalia Police Department has thoroughly researched various methods to prevent and respond to Part One crimes within the City of Visalia and County of Tulare.”
Let’s look at the “Background Discussion” presented by city staff in the agenda packet.
Background Discussion:
Flock Safety fixed-mount ALPR cameras have become one of the most popular ALPR cameras available to law enforcement and are also available to school districts, businesses, and hospitals.
True.
Currently, there are 18 Flock Safety fixed-mount ALPR cameras operating throughout the City of Visalia. These cameras are installed at various businesses and properties which are owned by private entities.
Also true.
As a Flock Safety customer, the Visalia Police Department would gain access to the 18 existing Flock Safety fixed-mount ALPR cameras at no additional cost. This would expand the network of ALPR cameras available to the Visalia Police Department significantly.
True.
Nationwide, all law enforcement owned Flock Safety ALPR cameras…
Not true. No Flock Safety ALPR cameras are owned by anyone other than Flock. They are the sole property of Flock. The City is entering into a lease.
communicate with each other, allowing law enforcement to track offenders from jurisdictions outside of the City of Visalia.
The cameras do not ‘communicate’ with each other. They take images, scan those images with a program to extract the license plate number, and send the image and the data to a central server, maintained as proprietary by Flock. The images can be further analyzed by Flock’s proprietary software for information other than simply license plate numbers. They do allow law enforcement agencies from outside the City of Visalia to access that data – if they subscribe to the service, or present a subpoena.
Locally, Flock Safety fixed-mount ALPR cameras are installed in the following cities: Farmersville, Woodlake, Porterville, Lindsay, Tulare, Hanford, Lemoore, Corcoran, Orange Cove, Reedley, Fowler, and Fresno. These cities combined have a total of more than 250 Flock Safety fixed-mount ALPR cameras, which the Visalia Police Department would gain access to after becoming a customer.
True.
Flock Safety fixed-mount ALPR cameras have no infrastructure requirements resulting in zero utility costs. The cameras are powered by solar and utilize a wireless LTE connectivity. Flock Safety services, maintains, and replaces each fixed-mount ALPR camera at no additional cost for the contracted period.
True. If the cameras or other parts of the system fail, Flock will replace them. If they are damaged or stolen, the City pays to replace them, at over $600-$800 per camera. Damage to the solar panel, cell equipment, or other parts of the unit are extra.
Flock Safety is the only fixed-mount ALPR camera company that provides connectivity with the existing Flock Safety fixed-mount ALPR cameras that are installed throughout the City of Visalia and surrounding jurisdictions. They are also the only company that features technology that is capable of capturing vehicle identifiers other than license plates.
There’s an important bit of information that I suspect many hope flies by unnoticed. “vehicle identifiers other than license plates”. And the data is used to train their own, again proprietary, AI.
Fiscal Impact:
No new appropriations required at this time. There will be two (2) separate contracts due to separate funding sources. Contract #1 is for nine (9) cameras and contract #2 is for 13 Cameras. The cost variance between the two projects is primarily due to differences in equipment and installation infrastructure.
I also have questions about the funding source, but that’s maybe for a different blog.
The ALPR cameras purchased under contract #1 are being installed on CalTrans right of way infrastructure which has an increased installation cost. Furthermore, two of the ALPR cameras included in this contract are more costly due to their range capabilities.
The cameras are not being “purchased”, they are being leased. While Flock claims, and contractually promises, that the data these cameras produce belong to the subscriber, and will not be ‘sold’, they do require “a non-exclusive, worldwide, perpetual, royalty-free right to use and distribute such Anonymized Data…”. There is no way (publicly revealed, anyway) for the City of Visalia to insure the data is secure, and not used in violation of California law, or the 4th Amendment to the US Constitution. (A class action lawsuit against Flock is in the beginning stages of court right now, based on 4th Amendment claims)
Purchased? Leased? Semantics? Maybe. But reading the Consent Agenda packet, would a City Council person necessarily understand that, one, the City was not “purchasing” the system, and, two, that the details presented in the agenda packet were not accurate? Many city council members rely heavily on the city staff to provide them with reliable information on which to base their decisions. Incomplete or misleading information, put in a consent calendar item, might reasonably fly right past them.
The Police Department recently told the Valley Voice that “according to their data, 2025 saw a 39% reduction in stolen vehicles, which VPD attributes to the Flock cameras it began using in 2024.” While that may be, correlation is not causation. We are not given the data required to authenticate the effectiveness of the Flock cameras.
As I’ve stated in previous blogs, I’m not against these kinds of camera systems, if they are the property of, controlled by, and accessed only by local government(s). With Flock, agencies do not control the system, they only have access to it. The data, while said to be owned by the agency and not sold to anyone else, is solely controlled by Flock. Past incidents have shown the ease at which access control is lost, and how the system can be abused, even by authorized personnel.
Look at the Consent Calendar agenda item yourself, and decide. Did it accurately reflect what the Police Department wanted the City to do? Does it fully inform the Council about what they were being asked to authorize? Did it really result in a 39% reduction in stolen vehicles?
Or is “lease” and “purchase” just an issue of semantics?
Here are my previous blogs about Flock:
- What the Flock?
- Well, Flock Me!
- More Flock, more fun
- Flock you later
- Flock the Lawyers
- Flock Me A Little Bit
- Tick tock tick Flock
- The Final Flock – and the answer is “NO”
- Hidden in the Flock
- Reason me this, Flock
- Flock Me – Round 2
- Another Flock of Cameras in Visalia
- The Flock Was Startled
- Half A Million Flocks in May, 2026
- Can I See Your Flock?
- Flock and Ding Dong Dash in Porterville
- Is Visalia PD following it’s own License Plate Reader policy regarding Flock cameras?










Is Visalia PD following it’s own License Plate Reader policy regarding Flock cameras?
September 6, 2026
Jim Reeves commentary, geek, News ai, ALPR, Flock, Flock Camera, Flock License Plate Reader, License Plate Reader, News, tchnology, visalia, visalia police department, VPD Leave a comment
The Visalia Police Department Policy manual includes the following section (online as of 5 pm Pacific, 9/6/2026):
The devil’s in the details, as they say, and boy are there some details here! Let’s take a look.
428.3
“…to convert data associated with vehicle license plates for official law enforcement purposes, including identifying stolen or wanted vehicles, stolen license plates and missing persons. It may also be used to gather information related to active warrants, homeland security, electronic surveillance, suspect interdiction and stolen property recovery.”
“Homeland Security”. California law prohibits the release of ALPR data generated in California to Federal agencies.
California Civil Code § 1798.90.51: Mandates that an ALPR operator or end-user must not share ALPR data with agencies or entities that are not state or local law enforcement agencies operating strictly under California state law.
California Civil Code § 1798.90.55: Prohibits public agencies from selling, sharing, or transferring ALPR information, limiting valid dissemination solely to authorized local/state public agencies operating within California for defined law enforcement purposes.
As long as they’re operating only based on California law, and not in conjunction with any Federal or out-of-state agency, they could, theoretically, use ALPR data for a perceived “homeland security” threat. But if they call in the Feds, they can’t give any of the ALPR data that they developed from their investigation to them.
Here’s the real devil, in my opinion, though:
428.7
(a) The agency makes a written request for the ALPR data that includes:
(b) The request is reviewed by the Operations Support Division Captain or the authorized
designee and approved before the request is fulfilled.
(c) The approved request is retained on file.
On 9/6/2026, there were 258 agencies listed on the Visalia Police Department’s Flock Transparency page as “Sharing Network Data With – Organizations granted access to Visalia CA PD data.”
From May 1, 2026 through June 1, 2026, there were 507,696 “hits” on Visalia PD’s Flock data set. California Highway Patrol was the biggest user, with 46,693 inquiries. That’s just one month’s worth of data access. (Visalia PD accessed the data only 1,634 times in that month, for comparison.)
Somehow, I doubt Visalia Police Department received 507,696 written requests for information which included the name of the agency, the requesting officer’s name, and the purpose for obtaining the information, which was then processed and approved before the data was released.
Now, I’m not a lawyer. I’ve never played one on TV. Hell, I didn’t even stay in a Holiday Inn Express last night. But it seems to me that the rule book isn’t being followed. The data is being accessed randomly by any agency on the “granted” list unsupervised. None of the required review or approvals are being done. Visalia PD has simply opened it’s data to anyone on that list. (To be sure, it’s a pretty common way to operate, as far as I can determine, statewide. Agencies all over the state are allowing the same access. The policy manual is one that is from a template, used by many agencies, and modified to reflect Visalia-specific regulation. One wonders how well it’s read before operations begin.)
I’m not universally against license plate reader systems. They have legitimate uses in the law enforcement world. What I don’t like is agencies, and especially the Visalia Police Department, giving control of these systems to an outside organization. The data is taken by cameras not owned by Visalia, the data is stored on servers not under the physical control of Visalia, and the programs used to access that data are proprietary property of Flock. The only real security on the data is Flock saying, “trust us, bro”. News reports the past few years tell us we can’t.
There are plenty of other ‘devils’ playing in this ongoing drama with Flock. Their use of the data, regardless of their claims that the customers own and control it and they won’t sell it, even though there are three places in the contract where the following is stated: “Customer hereby grants Flock a non-exclusive, worldwide, perpetual, royalty-free right to use and distribute such Anonymized Data to improve and enhance the Services and for other development, diagnostic and corrective purposes, and other Flock offerings.”
They also will use the data, anonymized (whatever that means. How do you anonymize data but still do this) to teach their AI program: “including the training of machine learning algorithms.”
Automated License Plate Readers are the camel’s nose. The rest of the camel is all the things they will (not can, will) do with the data we pay them to collect. The nose is in the tent. Maybe the camel has his entire head inside.
Did you ever watch the TV show, “Person of Interest”? Mr. Finch was trying to create an AI that could hunt terrorists. He succeeded. A joke of the show was that before he could create that machine, he had to create the availability of data, so he created social media. Now everyone provided the data he needed to train his AI. If you followed the show, you know how well all of that turned out.
We have some decisions to make. And some decisions already made to overturn. At the very least, change the policy manual to reflect how things are actually done.
Or we can just trust the government to always do the right thing, and protect us from bad actors. We’ve seen how well that’s worked out in the past, haven’t we?
My previous Flock-related posts:
Share this:
Like this: