There’s been some celebrating in LGBTQ circles today regarding a settlement agreement between Tastries bakery of Bakersfield, and the California Civil Rights Department. I don’t see the agreement as worthy of any celebrations. The LGBTQ community didn’t really win anything here.
There’s some important “fine print” in this agreement, that, for me, negates any celebrations.
“Provide non-customized products, including cakes, to all customers, regardless of sexual orientation or other protected characteristics.“
“Non-customized” products. That means they’ll sell you a cake, but if you want to put ‘his-name and his-name‘ on it, the agreement doesn’t require they do so. If you want a blank cake, or one that is a generic ‘congratulations!’, Tastries would have no grounds to refuse under this agreement, even if they know it’s for a LGBTQ event.
This agreement does not require Tastries to do much more than they were already doing. They can still refuse to create a cake decorated to celebrate a gay wedding. It’s only the “generic” products that are protected from discrimination by the bakery.
In this case, the California Civil Rights Department said “Tastries refused to sell a generic, multi-purpose white cake to a lesbian couple,” What is not included in this action is another incident that occurred on the same day, at the same bakery. See my Alternating Currents blog post about “Bakersfield Bakery Refuses Gay Couple“. In that incident, the owner of the bakery, Cathy Miller, turned away a gay couple who were at the business to conduct a “tasting” test, in preparation to place an order. Prior to this stage in the process, store staff, fully aware of the nature of the order, were happy and eager to help this couple. It was only when the owner became aware that customers were a gay couple did she then “refer” them to another bakery. She refused to provide the service because the cake would have both of the grooms names on it.
Here is the Consent Decree agreed to by the owner of the bakery, Miller, and CCRD:
This agreement is good for five years. After that…
The lawsuit and ongoing legal process was initiated by the lesbian couple, but the gay couple, not interested in the publicity this would generate, did not want to pursue legal recourse themselves.
I have also heard, but cannot verify, that other gay couples were refused service at Tastries at about the same time.
These were not isolated incidents. This bakery used their alleged Christian “faith” as the reason they would not provide a cake for a gay marriage ceremony. They won at the first court, but that was overturned at the appellate court level. Both the California and United States Supreme Courts refused to hear appeals, so the appellate court ruling stands. This agreement finalizes the court ruling and sets requirements on the bakery.
It’s not a big win for the LGBT community. It’s a minor concession, and if we’re going to celebrate, lets only get cupcakes. It’s not enough to justify a whole cake.
Random thoughts, occasional rants, illuminating commentary, and an odd story now and then from the world of 9-1-1 dispatching. All this and more from a gay liberal atheist living in California’s Bible belt. I recently married, so MAGA beware! I’m your worst nightmare! Some names have been omitted to protect the innocent, but the guilty will be hung out to dry!
Tastries agreement – hold the horses
November 16, 2026
Jim Reeves commentary, Gay, News, Personal Bakersfield bakery refuses lesbian couple, California Civil Rights Department, California Unruh Act, gay marriage, LGBTQ discrimination, marriage equality, Tastries 1 Comment
There’s been some celebrating in LGBTQ circles today regarding a settlement agreement between Tastries bakery of Bakersfield, and the California Civil Rights Department. I don’t see the agreement as worthy of any celebrations. The LGBTQ community didn’t really win anything here.
There’s some important “fine print” in this agreement, that, for me, negates any celebrations.
“Provide non-customized products, including cakes, to all customers, regardless of sexual orientation or other protected characteristics.“
“Non-customized” products. That means they’ll sell you a cake, but if you want to put ‘his-name and his-name‘ on it, the agreement doesn’t require they do so. If you want a blank cake, or one that is a generic ‘congratulations!’, Tastries would have no grounds to refuse under this agreement, even if they know it’s for a LGBTQ event.
This agreement does not require Tastries to do much more than they were already doing. They can still refuse to create a cake decorated to celebrate a gay wedding. It’s only the “generic” products that are protected from discrimination by the bakery.
In this case, the California Civil Rights Department said “Tastries refused to sell a generic, multi-purpose white cake to a lesbian couple,” What is not included in this action is another incident that occurred on the same day, at the same bakery. See my Alternating Currents blog post about “Bakersfield Bakery Refuses Gay Couple“. In that incident, the owner of the bakery, Cathy Miller, turned away a gay couple who were at the business to conduct a “tasting” test, in preparation to place an order. Prior to this stage in the process, store staff, fully aware of the nature of the order, were happy and eager to help this couple. It was only when the owner became aware that customers were a gay couple did she then “refer” them to another bakery. She refused to provide the service because the cake would have both of the grooms names on it.
Here is the Consent Decree agreed to by the owner of the bakery, Miller, and CCRD:
This agreement is good for five years. After that…
The lawsuit and ongoing legal process was initiated by the lesbian couple, but the gay couple, not interested in the publicity this would generate, did not want to pursue legal recourse themselves.
I have also heard, but cannot verify, that other gay couples were refused service at Tastries at about the same time.
These were not isolated incidents. This bakery used their alleged Christian “faith” as the reason they would not provide a cake for a gay marriage ceremony. They won at the first court, but that was overturned at the appellate court level. Both the California and United States Supreme Courts refused to hear appeals, so the appellate court ruling stands. This agreement finalizes the court ruling and sets requirements on the bakery.
It’s not a big win for the LGBT community. It’s a minor concession, and if we’re going to celebrate, lets only get cupcakes. It’s not enough to justify a whole cake.
And don’t order them from Tastries.
Share this:
Like this: